• For users coming over from tmlfans.ca your username will remain the same but you will need to use the password reset feature (check your spam folder) on the login page in order to set your password. If you encounter issues, email Rick couchmanrick@gmail.com

Armchair GM Thread 2025/26


Rough list. Here's how I would rank them for the Leafs:

1) Tuch 2) Raddysh -> They'll both get wild contracts, arguably more than they deserve, but we have room and a pretty big need for both players so I'd be ok taking a run at either

3) Carlson 4) Andersson -> Either would be a back-up option to Raddysh, Carlson obviously being more of a short-term fix

5) Zuccarello -> I really doubt he ends up leaving Minnesota, but if he does going from setting up Kaprizov to setting up Matthews for a little bit would be pretty appealing to him I think

6-10) McMann, Malkin, Schwartz, Marchment, Arvidsson -> All left wingers, which I don't really think is a pressing need at the moment considering our depth chart. Possibly a role for one of them if we moved bodies out

13) Ferraro -> Solid player, but we have enough players like him already and the focus just needs to be on bringing in more puck movers on the back-end. Toronto born guy though and pretty young for a UFA. If the price is right maybe they can get him as a replacement for a traded OEL

12, 13) Coyle, Trouba -> Mild interest in both veterans as they're coming off pretty strong seasons but I just don't really see it happening. Coyle is going to get multiple bank trucks dropping money off for him considering the C market

14, 15) Mantha, Kane -> Guys I liked in the past but I think the ship has sailed there

16) Stanley -> Nah

17-19) Bobrovsky, Skinner, Andersen -> Obviously just no need

20) Ovi -> As fun as it would be even in the extremely rare event that he would entertain playing for another NHL team the fit just isn't there
 
It's actually a pretty solid list imo. Everyone focuses on franchise players being available but I'd take a lot of those guys on the Leafs.
 
It's going to have to be trades.

Ducks have benched Zellweger and McTavish

Dallas is in a cap crunch with Robertson’s next deal. Can we pry out Harley (new big deal kicking in) or Heiskanen (NMC)? Mavrik Bourque?
 
Mike Reilly, Mark Jankowski, and Jeff Mallott are 3 lower-priced upcoming UFA's I think the Leafs should target.
Why? I don't see what any of them bring to this team. Jankowski has a whopping 4pts in 30 playoff games and the other 2 bring literally no offence. Would rather run with some younger guys
 
Back
Top