Frycer14 said:
CarltonTheBear said:
Guilt Trip said:
Frycer14 said:
I was excited about the acquisition, but after watching him play, I've very, very pessimistic about Thornton playing a top 6 role.
CTB has the numbers but Matthews with Joe and Marner were like 73% Corsi..the same hasn't been true with Hyman even though the line has produced.
JT and Willy need to get going so Keefe is hoping Hyman can help them.
If Matthews didn't shoot like 4% or whatever it was to start the season absolutely nobody would be questioning Thornton's spot on that line.
I would. It was beyond obvious that thornton wasn't keeping up with M&M on line rushes. He simply can't play the game at the pace that the other two play at. The idea that he's an upgrade over Hyman is simply ludicrous. I don't know what Keefe was thinking putting him on the top line.
I thought he was acquired to play 3rd line center, and even then, he might be better on the wing.
This is what is seemed like to me. M&M seemed to be succeeding largely in spite of Thornton, not because of him. Hyman is a far better match on that line. The question is, once Thornton is back where does he go. Does it make sense to try Hyman with Tavares and Nylander to give them a boost? I might be tempted to try putting Thornton at 3rd line center and moving Kerfoot up to LW on one of the top 2 lines. At least he can keep up and maybe that inspires him to play better.
Ultimately I think we need to get Robertson into the top 6 and see what he can provide. Not sure if he's ready for it yet, based on what I saw in the play in series against Columbus.