Highlander
Active member
anyone who wants to play Frazer over someone like Liles is an idiot. Sorry Randy but you have lost the thread and it is time for a change
John Michael Liles - Carolina
- Thread starter L K
- Start date
OldTimeHockey
Active member
Come on people, don't act like Liles wasn't the contract that most wanted the Leafs to buyout this off season.
BlueWhiteBlood
New member
OldTimeHockey said:
Guilty as charged! However if Nonis would have done it when I suggested it, he would have had a few bucks around to fix "Carlyle's bottom 6" right now.
GhostofPotvin29
New member
It would have made more sense to use the compliance buy out on him, let Komisarek's run out, and free up that space. Especially if the coach wasn't going to use him. If they weren't going to buy him out I'd rather have seen him playing, but now we have Gleason's slightly higher hit instead.
Highlander
Active member
higher hit?.but lower buy out terms?.Rutherford gets a decent puck moving defenseman that RC cannot stand and we get a sack of potatoes that ultimately will cost us less
OldTimeHockey
Active member
I'm not debating whether or not it would of been the right move to buy him out or trade him. I'm also not debating that keeping Komisarek would of been the right move or not.
I'm questioning those that are upset that Liles isn't on the team. People around here wrote Liles off last season.
I like Liles. I think he stills has gas in the tank. He was shoehorned into being a goat for a while and I don't think it was necessarily just.
I'm questioning those that are upset that Liles isn't on the team. People around here wrote Liles off last season.
I like Liles. I think he stills has gas in the tank. He was shoehorned into being a goat for a while and I don't think it was necessarily just.
L K
Active member
OldTimeHockey said:
You are right. I did want Liles bought out over Komisarek. But once that didn't happen, there was no reason to not play him. As nice has Rielly has been this year, he looks like an overmatched rookie on a lot of nights. His defensive game still needs a lot of work and he doesn't have the physical strength to win puck battles yet. There was no need to rush him to the NHL over Liles once the decision was made to keep him.
There was no reason to keep him in the AHL when the team was struggling to provide offense and Fraser was hobbling up and down the ice.
There was no reason to trade him for a guy who was having a terrible season for a team that until recently was behind us in the standings.
Over a 6 game stretch (4 for Liles, 2 for Gleason) there is a net:
Carolina: 1G 0A 1P +8 +1 hits +6 blocked shot
Toronto: 0G 0A 0P -8 -1 hits -6 blocked shots
Syntax McLawdog
New member
bustaheims said:
And this is where i put a full stop.