• For users coming over from tmlfans.ca your username will remain the same but you will need to use the password reset feature (check your spam folder) on the login page in order to set your password. If you encounter issues, email Rick at: couchmanrick@gmail.com

Kings @ Leafs - Nov. 19th, 7:00pm - SN

When is someone in the organization going to address the officiating. Matthews got a crosscheck to the neck and was tackled. He never gets calls.
I have not said as much about the officiating because you have faithfully taken care of it. I often check to see if you have already weighed in before I say something about it :)
Thank you for that. Saved me some typing.

That call last night where the LA dman lifted his stick upward to help the puck go over the glass was a penalty. Four officials meet ... no call. In the previous game, a Leafs player got tripped trying to come out from behind the Leafs net ... nothing. Seems to happen nearly every game. Yet some of the calls on the Leafs seem marginal to me but not on the other team.

I guess I'm a little biased as a Leafs fan but I think it has been worse this year and increasingly worse in recent years.
 
The officiating really has been atrocious. The can opener on MacEwan had MJ freaking out live on broadcast which you normally don't see. Then Doughty can beat the shit out of Matthews in front of the net. And I saw a replay where Tavares got called on a hook that literally wasn't a hook. They also didn't call Byfield sending the puck over glass. It's been awful.
I wonder if this all started once Matthews made fun of the refs that one game where he scored and started pointing at the net? I mean that's a long time to hold a grudge, but this has been a bit of a problem for years now. The Leafs are always the lowest to draw penalties in the league, and by a far margin.

You can say "Well play style" only so much before we as fans start noticing the blatant missed calls that happen every game against this team. Once in a while, sure it's an accident. But when a pattern starts to emerge game after game, something is up.

I mean, the Byfield knocking the puck out of the rink last night was a perfect example. That is an automatic call. He hit the puck with his stick to change the direction of the puck and it went out of the arena. That call has to happen. No matter game situation, score, or if there is already a penalty occurring. The fact that they went to talk about it for 5 minutes and then come back to say "Yeah it's a non-call" makes me think that they were having the conversation to come up with a justification to not make the call.

And I garauntee that if the shoe was on the other foot, the Leaf player doing that would have been penalized.

This is the sort of thing that I mean when I start talking about time and money being the only vote we the fans get. Maybe it isn't against the Leafs, but the whole NHL. Like we aren't going to watch your crappy product if there is still a perceived bias.
 
Last edited:
I don't think the refs are out to get the Leafs, but I do think they are very bad in general. But I also don't think that's new. Worst reffing in sports! They don't even try as a league to improve it. I mean the confusion of what's goaltender interference alone has been a joke for years. They make zero effort to improve it.
 
I don't think the refs are out to get the Leafs, but I do think they are very bad in general. But I also don't think that's new. Worst reffing in sports! They don't even try as a league to improve it. I mean the confusion of what's goaltender interference alone has been a joke for years. They make zero effort to improve it.
For clarity, I also do not think there is a broad conspiracy within the refs that are out to get the Leafs. There may be personal stuff going on with some refs but I really doubt it is broad.
I guess it is more like all the posts they have been hitting. The reffing quality seems to have gone down and the Leafs seem to be suffering more from it than their opponents.
 
I don't think the refs are out to get the Leafs, but I do think they are very bad in general. But I also don't think that's new. Worst reffing in sports! They don't even try as a league to improve it. I mean the confusion of what's goaltender interference alone has been a joke for years. They make zero effort to improve it.
Yeah but when is the last game that this bad reffing benefitted the Leafs? Bad reffing can be a thing, but then that bad reffing should affect both teams equally? If it's just bad luck, well then if it wasn't for bad luck, the Leafs would have no luck at all in these situations.
 
McKenna pulled a Nylander with a stop up.
When the actual end goal is winning the puck, I don't really have an issue with McKenna pulling up when he knew he a) had no chance to take the puck clean b) would be more useful to the team as a player rather than as paste on the boards. There's certainly a time and place to take the body and eat a hit to make a play, but this isn't one, and he goes and wins the puck after anyway.
 
Yeah but when is the last game that this bad reffing benefitted the Leafs? Bad reffing can be a thing, but then that bad reffing should affect both teams equally? If it's just bad luck, well then if it wasn't for bad luck, the Leafs would have no luck at all in these situations.
I can't pinpoint a game, but I remember games where I think it was bad reffing in the Leafs favour. I want to say there was a false high stick we got a PP for earlier this year, but I can't remember. I think we notice the calls against much more easily than calls for. You know, personal bias. Come on, we all have it to some degree!
 
I do wonder if we are watching the last games of Matthews as a Leaf before the deadline. He's been our best player game in and game out, a complete player, a competitor, still in the top echelon as a scorer.

But what he isn't, anymore, is a game-breaker. A guy you could count on to have multiple 2-goal games and several hat tricks each season.

I honestly am baffled by how little he tries his deadly wrister nowadays. They don't seem to have any ideas for getting him into position in the middle of the ice to try it on PPs.

Anyway, with this season all but gone already they have to make the big decision soon to blow it up — finally — and move on to trying to rebuild the team around McKenna. I wouldn't be surprised if the only one of 34, 88, 44, 91 left after the deadline is Tavares, who I can't imagine wanting to move on.
 
Problem with that is he told Pelley it could be done (that is what Pelley wanted and therefore, what he wanted to hear). It was probably a key assurance that got Chayka hired because I'm sure a number of candidates proposed a rebuild.
Apparently, Chayka signed a long term contract so he might be hard for Pelley to axe.
They have no cap room to do much. They have few prospects they can part with. Their only viable option if they're resistant to throwing in the towel and burning more young assets is trying another coach. But they're looking at having to play .675 hockey the rest of the way to make the playoffs. That's hard to pull off with an injury prone old team.
I bet Bruce Boudreau would give it a shot.
I'm not sure Tortorella would due to the stench of roster rigor mortis. He's likely to have better options.
Yeah my hope would be he told Pelley what he wanted to hear to get the job. He’s done what he was hired to do. Now he can say “look we tried. It didn’t and can’t work. Let’s start over”. And the long term contract lets him do it cos they don’t want to pay him off. And they can’t really fire him for doing what they wanted.
 
Yeah my hope would be he told Pelley what he wanted to hear to get the job. He’s done what he was hired to do. Now he can say “look we tried. It didn’t and can’t work. Let’s start over”. And the long term contract lets him do it cos they don’t want to pay him off. And they can’t really fire him for doing what they wanted.
Hmmm ..
He got the job claiming he could get them into the playoffs if they gave him the chance as GM (what Pelley wanted to hear vs rebuild he didn't want).

He gave Bobrovsky $21 M deal
Raddysh $68M deal
Overpaid 3rd/4th liner UFAs ~$10M
Trade added to get Paul $3.5M
Signed Rosolvic $8M
etc (rough numbers ignoring Marchenko)
He hired the coaching staff for millions on top of the millions paid to those fired
They had to pay severance to all the MLSE employees they terminated and all those they hired to replace them
They're basically capped out this year and next with this group.

Chayka spent/committed well beyond ~$110+M of their money plus many millions in severance/new employees for a .396 hockey team that currently has between a ~1% to 8% chance of making the playoffs
Not only are they staring at missing the playoffs this year. Next year doesn't look too rosy either as they're nearly all signed up for that
This failure will cause them to lose Auston Matthews because they have little hope of re-signing him after this fiasco as he wants to play on a contender

They have a pretty good case to fire Chayka for just cause.
Their trust in him has to have been seriously eroded

Now, Pelley hired him so he's not looking too good to the MLSE board either. Chayka & Pelley may try to get each other's back ....
Who knows ?
They do have a slim chance of turning it around but it is tough with a roster frozen financially with cap issues.

Some on the MLSE board have good reason to be pissed off/very disappointed and therefore, fire somebody. I do not think this is likely to end well for some of the people responsible for this.
Pelley does not appear to have what he thought he was getting.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: Arn
I do wonder if we are watching the last games of Matthews as a Leaf before the deadline. He's been our best player game in and game out, a complete player, a competitor, still in the top echelon as a scorer.

But what he isn't, anymore, is a game-breaker. A guy you could count on to have multiple 2-goal games and several hat tricks each season.

I honestly am baffled by how little he tries his deadly wrister nowadays. They don't seem to have any ideas for getting him into position in the middle of the ice to try it on PPs.

Anyway, with this season all but gone already they have to make the big decision soon to blow it up — finally — and move on to trying to rebuild the team around McKenna. I wouldn't be surprised if the only one of 34, 88, 44, 91 left after the deadline is Tavares, who I can't imagine wanting to move on.
The writing was on the wall when he signed a 4 year deal instead of 8 yrs.
That writing got clearer when Marner was allowed to depart and they did not get equitable talent return.
Brett Hull's goal scoring took a dive when Adam Oates departed. I think Marner's departure has compromised Matthews goal scoring similarly and probably his injuries have had some detrimental effect.

The trajectory of this team is not likely to change in a meaningful way for Matthews. We had a pretty good idea of that when Marner departed. The most they have had to offer is a bubble team and that bubble is close to bursting - after firing all kinds of people and turning over half the roster and nearly all the coaching staff.

The object of a team in this league is to win a Cup. With Matthews having the balance of this year and next on his contract, trading him to a team so they could have two playoff runs with Matthews is worth much more than trading him for one playoff run. They have to look at maximizing their asset return before this year's deadline. Waiting for a sign and trade could result in a poor return like they got for Marner or nothing. Being a top 10 scorer & a two way center who wins draws ... they should get a great return.

With his injury history, they would be wise to do so sooner than later.

Two things will stick with me about him that have him rise above his Rocket goal scoring seasons. He's been a two way hockey player. He didn't goal suck to get those goals. Both ends of the ice mattered to him. And recently, during this terrible losing streak, he showed up and played his heart out in both ends trying to help his team. I have a lot more respect for that than 69 goal seasons.
 
Hmmm ..
He got the job claiming he could get them into the playoffs if they gave him the chance as GM (what Pelley wanted to hear vs rebuild he didn't want).

He gave Bobrovsky $21 M deal
Raddysh $68M deal
Overpaid 3rd/4th liner UFAs ~$10M
Trade added to get Paul $3.5M
Signed Rosolvic $8M
etc (rough numbers ignoring Marchenko)
He hired the coaching staff for millions on top of the millions paid to those fired
They had to pay severance to all the MLSE employees they terminated and all those they hired to replace them
They're basically capped out this year and next with this group.

Chayka spent/committed well beyond ~$110+M of their money plus many millions in severance/new employees for a .396 hockey team that currently has between a ~1% to 8% chance of making the playoffs
Not only are they staring at missing the playoffs this year. Next year doesn't look too rosy either as they're nearly all signed up for that
This failure will cause them to lose Auston Matthews because they have little hope of re-signing him after this fiasco as he wants to play on a contender

They have a pretty good case to fire Chayka for just cause.
Their trust in him has to have been seriously eroded

Now, Pelley hired him so he's not looking too good to the MLSE board either. Chayka & Pelley may try to get each other's back ....
Who knows ?
They do have a slim chance of turning it around but it is tough with a roster frozen financially with cap issues.

Some on the MLSE board have good reason to be pissed off/very disappointed and therefore, fire somebody. I do not think this is likely to end well for some of the people responsible for this.
Pelley does not appear to have what he thought he was getting.
Pelley also can't read the room on a basic level. He comes off as an arrogant prick who knows next to nothing beyond marketing, except fans can smell that a mile away. The constant reminders in broadcast to buy a jersey as they fritter away a game is embarassing and Pelley being front and centre in a shot with Rory and the team is one of the most tone deaf and bad looks I can remember from anyone above the GM.
 
  • Like
Reactions: cw
The writing was on the wall when he signed a 4 year deal instead of 8 yrs.
That writing got clearer when Marner was allowed to depart and they did not get equitable talent return.
Brett Hull's goal scoring took a dive when Adam Oates departed. I think Marner's departure has compromised Matthews goal scoring similarly and probably his injuries have had some detrimental effect.

The trajectory of this team is not likely to change in a meaningful way for Matthews. We had a pretty good idea of that when Marner departed. The most they have had to offer is a bubble team and that bubble is close to bursting - after firing all kinds of people and turning over half the roster and nearly all the coaching staff.

The object of a team in this league is to win a Cup. With Matthews having the balance of this year and next on his contract, trading him to a team so they could have two playoff runs with Matthews is worth much more than trading him for one playoff run. They have to look at maximizing their asset return before this year's deadline. Waiting for a sign and trade could result in a poor return like they got for Marner or nothing. Being a top 10 scorer & a two way center who wins draws ... they should get a great return.

With his injury history, they would be wise to do so sooner than later.

Two things will stick with me about him that have him rise above his Rocket goal scoring seasons. He's been a two way hockey player. He didn't goal suck to get those goals. Both ends of the ice mattered to him. And recently, during this terrible losing streak, he showed up and played his heart out in both ends trying to help his team. I have a lot more respect for that than 69 goal seasons.
Funny enough the older I get the less impressed I am with raw point totals and the more I am with getting points while also playing a responsible 200ft game.
 
  • Like
Reactions: cw
Hmmm ..
He got the job claiming he could get them into the playoffs if they gave him the chance as GM (what Pelley wanted to hear vs rebuild he didn't want).

He gave Bobrovsky $21 M deal
Raddysh $68M deal
Overpaid 3rd/4th liner UFAs ~$10M
Trade added to get Paul $3.5M
Signed Rosolvic $8M
etc (rough numbers ignoring Marchenko)
He hired the coaching staff for millions on top of the millions paid to those fired
They had to pay severance to all the MLSE employees they terminated and all those they hired to replace them
They're basically capped out this year and next with this group.

Chayka spent/committed well beyond ~$110+M of their money plus many millions in severance/new employees for a .396 hockey team that currently has between a ~1% to 8% chance of making the playoffs
Not only are they staring at missing the playoffs this year. Next year doesn't look too rosy either as they're nearly all signed up for that
This failure will cause them to lose Auston Matthews because they have little hope of re-signing him after this fiasco as he wants to play on a contender

They have a pretty good case to fire Chayka for just cause.
Their trust in him has to have been seriously eroded

Now, Pelley hired him so he's not looking too good to the MLSE board either. Chayka & Pelley may try to get each other's back ....
Who knows ?
They do have a slim chance of turning it around but it is tough with a roster frozen financially with cap issues.

Some on the MLSE board have good reason to be pissed off/very disappointed and therefore, fire somebody. I do not think this is likely to end well for some of the people responsible for this.
Pelley does not appear to have what he thought he was getting.
Pelley is more the issue to me.

Shanahan didn’t work out, obviously, but I do think you need a “hockey man(or woman)” in that level of role.

One who’s willing to be honest with the board.

I’d not be averse to Pelley going and being replaced by someone like that.

I dunno if Pelley goes if Chayka has to go too. I think Chayka has some security in that he’s done what he was told to do. Apart from really the Bobrovsky move I think you can see the (loose) logic behind the moves he made with the end goal he was given.

I guess if you gave him the job of rebuilding “properly” he maybe has earned a shot? You could argue it either way I think to be fair.

I think it’s time to do that though, whoever is in charge of it.

On your points in your other post about Matthews, I most gutted that it probably is his time to move on cos I think he’s finally now matured into a great leader in terms of what he’s doing on the ice. I’d love to see him be a career Leaf and set every points record going. I don’t think that’s likely now sadly.
 
I can't pinpoint a game, but I remember games where I think it was bad reffing in the Leafs favour. I want to say there was a false high stick we got a PP for earlier this year, but I can't remember. I think we notice the calls against much more easily than calls for. You know, personal bias. Come on, we all have it to some degree!
I agree we all have personal bias. I went back and looked at the penalties for and against. For the most part the number of powerplays are pretty even. There are just a couple of outliers where the Leafs didn't get a powerplay chance at all, like the Devils game. That's the game though where they didn't skate at all so that probably explains it. I agree that it's probably just a thing that fans grasp on to because of the losing streak.
 
Last edited:
Funny enough the older I get the less impressed I am with raw point totals and the more I am with getting points while also playing a responsible 200ft game.
In the '60s, we got a pretty good education on that:
Dave Keon, ~160lbs, smart, good skater, good at faceoffs and great defensively. He led the team in scoring some years but a big thing was his ability to shutdown franchise players. Along with him, they converted Detroit Norris winner Red Kelly to center and he was great defensively. 4 Cups - '67 was stolen by the Leafs in my opinion
In '72, the Russians, after facing all those NHL stars on Team Canada, raved about Bob Gainey's defensive play - not the stars. We kind of went "huh?" Woke us up. The Selke trophy was born.
Look at the Selke winners after that.
Media has always fussed over those who rack up points and less about those who are good defensively. Contracts have been awarded accordingly.

There are guys in the HHoF who were goal sucks and only played one way in my opinion. I still don't accept them the same way.
 
Pelley is more the issue to me.

Shanahan didn’t work out, obviously, but I do think you need a “hockey man(or woman)” in that level of role.

One who’s willing to be honest with the board.

I’d not be averse to Pelley going and being replaced by someone like that.

I dunno if Pelley goes if Chayka has to go too. I think Chayka has some security in that he’s done what he was told to do. Apart from really the Bobrovsky move I think you can see the (loose) logic behind the moves he made with the end goal he was given.

I guess if you gave him the job of rebuilding “properly” he maybe has earned a shot? You could argue it either way I think to be fair.

I think it’s time to do that though, whoever is in charge of it.

On your points in your other post about Matthews, I most gutted that it probably is his time to move on cos I think he’s finally now matured into a great leader in terms of what he’s doing on the ice. I’d love to see him be a career Leaf and set every points record going. I don’t think that’s likely now sadly.
This past spring, they interviewed a bunch of candidates. I'm sure there were those who advocated for a rebuild. They already seem to be pushing Pelley to the side. Bring in the most impressive candidate who advocated for a rebuild.

Hard to see Chayka rebound into the second coming of Sam Pollack at this point.

All management makes mistakes. Good management fixes them quickly.
 
This past spring, they interviewed a bunch of candidates. I'm sure there were those who advocated for a rebuild. They already seem to be pushing Pelley to the side. Bring in the most impressive candidate who advocated for a rebuild.

Hard to see Chayka rebound into the second coming of Sam Pollack at this point.

All management makes mistakes. Good management fixes them quickly.
This feels like we'll be in the wilderness for some time before they understand the value of having someone with a ton of experience in the game and management to be the president of hockey ops and on down. This might turn out to be one of the darker periods in Leafs history.
 
This feels like we'll be in the wilderness for some time before they understand the value of having someone with a ton of experience in the game and management to be the president of hockey ops and on down. This might turn out to be one of the darker periods in Leafs history.
Just the age of the roster, shallow prospect system, capped out through next year ... it is going to take a while.
But in terms of being a contender, that wasn't possible last year either and is very unlikely next year and probably the year after or more
It is easier to get behind a younger team heading in the right direction.

Having said that, even though I wanted them to start a rebuild last year, I cannot muster cheering against them. The best thing for them would be to continue losing to jackhammer home to the MLSE board that it is time to rebuild. But I can't hope they lose - even though that would probably be for the best.

Pathetic Leafs fan ...
 

Members online

Forum statistics

Threads
3,004
Messages
409,825
Members
818
Latest member
puckhead103
Back
Top