• For users coming over from tmlfans.ca your username will remain the same but you will need to use the password reset feature (check your spam folder) on the login page in order to set your password. If you encounter issues, email Rick couchmanrick@gmail.com

Leafs All-Time Top 100 Speculation Thread

bustaheims said:
TBLeafer said:
Because so much this is revolving around the '100' theme. I do think a qualifying factor for the list will be Leafs that have played 100 + games for them at a minimum.
Click to expand...

Even without the 100 theme, 100+ games is the bare minimum standard if you're looking at them in terms of their place in a specific team's history. Anything less than that, and they'd have to have made a significant impact in the team winning a championship, or had a season that was a relevant part of league history.
Click to expand...

League history or team history?  I think it can be said that Lindros had pretty relevant league history.  Leafs history?  Not so much unless you include scoring on them.
 
TBLeafer said:
League history or team history?  I think it can be said that Lindros had pretty relevant league history.  Leafs history?  Not so much unless you include scoring on them.
Click to expand...

Team history for the 100+ game threshold, or a season that was special in terms of the league's history in their only season on that team (which, I don't know if any Leafs qualify, but, it's not impossible). If, for instance, a player spent one year with the team, but won the Art Ross, Hart, etc., and the team won the Cup (or at least made the Final), I'd be open to considering them even though they played less than 100 regular season games with the team.
 
bustaheims said:
TBLeafer said:
League history or team history?  I think it can be said that Lindros had pretty relevant league history.  Leafs history?  Not so much unless you include scoring on them.
Click to expand...

Team history for the 100+ game threshold, or a season that was special in terms of the league's history in their only season on that team (which, I don't know if any Leafs qualify, but, it's not impossible). If, for instance, a player spent one year with the team, but won the Art Ross, Hart, etc., and the team won the Cup (or at least made the Final), I'd be open to considering them even though they played less than 100 regular season games with the team.
Click to expand...

Got it.  Do we even have any of those?  Hard to believe an award winning Leafs player in his first season on a winning team, wouldn't remain a Leaf the following season. 
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top