• For users coming over from tmlfans.ca your username will remain the same but you will need to use the password reset feature (check your spam folder) on the login page in order to set your password. If you encounter issues, email Rick at: couchmanrick@gmail.com

2026-27 Toronto Maple Leafs General Discussion | Official: Sundin & Chayka to lead front office

The Oilers will probably pound them tomorrow to avenge their earlier loss. Then they have 4 easier games. I'm going to see how those go before sticking a fork in them. Regardless, if they lose to the Oilers, they'll be a .409 team having to play .667 hockey the rest of the way to make the playoffs. So their situation is grim. They have little cap space and assets to rescue their season.
Think the Leafs could trade Marchenko or Nylander to get their first and Minten back?
 
Think the Leafs could trade Marchenko or Nylander to get their first and Minten back?

He'd waive to go to Boston to play with his buddy Pasta.

If Leafs got Carlo for Minten and a 1st, it feels criminal to trade Nylander for the same return.
 
Last edited:
Think the Leafs could trade Marchenko or Nylander to get their first and Minten back?
Boston is 3rd in GAA and they're 6th in GFA. They don't need Nylander messing up their D with his 100 foot game. Minten is doing well there, is younger and signed to a decent deal until he reaches UFA status.
Assuming they're going to blow it up, Marchenko should be considered to be moved before his no movement clause kicks in.
 
I actually clicked on one of the links of one of the stories referenced by the new front page of the site, which took me to an article on “The Hockey Writers”.

The opening line of said story reads “The Toronto Maple Leafs start the week looking to establish greater consistency as the season moves deeper into its opening months.”

I feel that’s a bit disingenuous. 6 losses in a row is very consistent.

(
 
The one thing I will say about the lineup is they look individually better.

Matthews coming into the offseason had two good but otherwise ordinary seasons under Berube. He had a big knee injury. Now we know he looks healthy. His line is pretty consistently the best one on the ice. If anything I think him being traded at the deadline is more valuable now than he would have been in July even though you are trading for less time.

Rielly...I'm not going to say he suddenly has massive value but I do think that 12 points in 18 games with secondary PP time helps his case pretty solidly that he can still contribute to a team.

Marchenko will have big value

Nylander will still have lots of value.

Roslovic should have value

I don't think this exercise hurt the team in terms of rebuilding and I think the most likely decision point is going to be more into February with the team either way.

That's also not to factor in that if the Leafs can right the ship enough to at least be competitive (and I do think their play over the last two weeks deserved better than 0 points) that keeping top 5 picks away from Boston and Philly isn't bad either way.
 
Last edited:


Please don’t trade for defence. Please don’t waste what minimal remaining assets there are on trying to flog a dead horse.

That sounds like something Treliving would do.



(Unless it’s Nylander for Werenski or something straight up I suppose)
 
Every system has flaws but I think the current personnel are uniquely suited to being quite bad at man-on-man defense.

So firing Berube didn't fix all the coaching problems?

Far be it from me to start second-guessing the whole Chayka/Hiller* hiring thing.






* matsnotincludedthatwasgenius
 
Alan Hahn was on the team 1050 this morning. He's a Knicks guy, and he brought up an interesting thought about roster construction for the Leafs. He said for years the Knicks believed that they needed to focus on star power in order to build a team. They thought that because whenever the stars came into Madison square garden, the mecca of basketball, the fans would show up to see them, and cheer them more than the team that was playing. He said the stars on the Knicks had a hard time getting up for the games because playing in the mecca of basketball becomes common after awhile. So other stars in the league would come in and outplay the stars on the Knicks just based on it being a grand stage for them to show off their talents.

What changed with the way the Knicks built their team, is they built it around a hard working, lunch pail, team unity identity. What that did is changed how the fans viewed the team. They cheered for the Knicks and not an individual player. They got better at home because the stars would come in, looking just to put on a show at Madison Square Garden, and suddenly realized that they were in a bit of a fight to win the game because the Knicks would just hound the other team relentlessly because of their workman like attitude.

You can draw parrallels of this to the Leafs, and I think this is why people get so frustrated with this team because it looks like they are disinterested while they are playing. That they lack commitment.

If you think back to the last time the Leafs were in the conference finals, that was when Quinn was running the team. The team he built did have this kind of identity and attitude. They were relentless. They weren't perfect, but they were hard to play against.

I think the Leafs need to keep Easton Cowan, and find more players like him to flush out the roster. Players who just want to hound the other team relentlessly if for no other reason than they like to play that way.
 
Having Sissons, Blueger, and Paul at the bottom of that list is not a good look for Chayka. These were the players you brought in to make this team better.

Chayka is supposed to be an analytics guy. What analytical research suggested giving Colton Sissons $4.25m x 2 years after scoring 11 points last season was a good idea? 😕
These numbers need context, which is not applied in this chart.

Blueger and Sissons and Paul get a steady diet of DZ starts, where inevitably, pucks get directed on net; I would expect them to be net negative on shot-chance +/- by nature of that deployment. It's showing up in Matthews' line in reverse (on top of Matthews being good), and I think most Leaf fans are happy to take that trade off.

Cap hit-wise, yeah it looks not good, but that's UFA. We don't know what other market pressures there were for Sissons specifically, but I do know there is always a premium for defensively useful right-handed centres just by virtue of scarcity.

People are going to look at Willy's big red negative, but take into consideration who he is working with on most nights, and what those actual numbers are relative to the team. I'm not saying he hasn't been bad (looks slow), but he's basically putting up similar to the most consistent first liners on the Leafs, but with a giveaway machine at centre. We expect more from him at his cap hit and team stature.
 
  • Like
Reactions: YYZ
Trading both Woll and Hildeby was the biggest mistake. Both of those guys have the better numbers on their respective teams.
They had three NHL goalies who were not waivers exempt so someone had to go or they could lose them for nothing.
Emil Andrae was a 7th on the lowly Flyers and couldn't crack the top 7 on Columbus. He's in the AHL.
Hildeby had the best save% & GAA numbers among the Leafs goalies last year and he's younger. Losing him may bite them
Signing a 38 year old goalie who was already showing signs of decline for $21 Mil bothered me.
 

Members online

Forum statistics

Threads
3,002
Messages
409,375
Members
817
Latest member
AndyC
Back
Top