Kin
Active member
RedLeaf said:Sure. Providing he has some defensive acumen.
That's going to be a pretty low bar, then, if it's one Evgeni Malkin can clear.
Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.
Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.
RedLeaf said:Sure. Providing he has some defensive acumen.
Nik the Trik said:RedLeaf said:Sure. Providing he has some defensive acumen.
That's going to be a pretty low bar, then, if it's one Evgeni Malkin can clear.
Highlander said:Kadri may have to switch to winger at some point probably when Bolland gets back.
RedLeaf said:I'm sure there are many exceptions to the rule out there. Gretzky comes to mind as being an average defender. I think it's a general rule that superstar offensive players can be exempt from being defensively strong players. I don't think you're really comparing Kadri to Malkin though, are you?
Nik the Trik said:RedLeaf said:I'm sure there are many exceptions to the rule out there. Gretzky comes to mind as being an average defender. I think it's a general rule that superstar offensive players can be exempt from being defensively strong players. I don't think you're really comparing Kadri to Malkin though, are you?
Well, the reason I was responding is because you were speaking in those kinds of absolutes. I mean, the expression is "the exception that proves the rule", right? If there are many exceptions to a rule, it's not a rule.
Joe S. said:I'm not following the logic of this thread at all. Essentially it's 'Kadri will not become a #1 centre and is weak defensively so trade him for a #1 centre who can score and is good defensively'.
Why and how would this magical trade happen?
Just hang on to him. Or the Leafs could repeat the Steen fiasco.
Joe S. said:I'm not following the logic of this thread at all. Essentially it's 'Kadri will not become a #1 centre and is weak defensively so trade him for a #1 centre who can score and is good defensively'.
Why and how would this magical trade happen?
Just hang on to him. Or the Leafs could repeat the Steen fiasco.
RedLeaf said:Joe S. said:I'm not following the logic of this thread at all. Essentially it's 'Kadri will not become a #1 centre and is weak defensively so trade him for a #1 centre who can score and is good defensively'.
Why and how would this magical trade happen?
Just hang on to him. Or the Leafs could repeat the Steen fiasco.
You're right. You don't get better value without sweetening the deal. I was assuming any deal to upgrade at centre would involve another player heading out with Kadri as well, unless it is one for one for Statsny (with an extension).
Joe S. said:I'm not following the logic of this thread at all. Essentially it's 'Kadri will not become a #1 centre and is weak defensively so trade him for a #1 centre who can score and is good defensively'.
Why and how would this magical trade happen?
Just hang on to him. Or the Leafs could repeat the Steen fiasco.
Potvin29 said:Joe S. said:I'm not following the logic of this thread at all. Essentially it's 'Kadri will not become a #1 centre and is weak defensively so trade him for a #1 centre who can score and is good defensively'.
Why and how would this magical trade happen?
Just hang on to him. Or the Leafs could repeat the Steen fiasco.
I'm assuming Antropov, Colaiacovo and a 1st are involved as well to sweeten the pot.
BlueWhiteBlood said:I can only speak for myself, but I don't think people are trying to push Kadri out the door, certainly not in a losing trade. If we could upgrade our team, why wouldn't you consider it?
Joe S. said:I didn't say I wouldn't consider it, if it improves the team obviously. What I'm trying to understand was the diminished view of Kadri and the unrealistic player(s) he could return in a trade.
The guy has top end offensive skills, you can see it, and I can't remember the last time the Leafs ever drafted a player like that and actually kept him. I'd just for once, like to see an natural scorer actually develop in Toronto for once.
All it costs the Leafs is time - if by the time he's 27 or so and he didn't pan out, then they can cut their losses.
Highlander said:Kadri may have to switch to winger at some point probably when Bolland gets back.
Corn Flake said:Highlander said:Kadri may have to switch to winger at some point probably when Bolland gets back.
Give him Mason Raymond's spot. Time to end that experiment.
Corn Flake said:Highlander said:Kadri may have to switch to winger at some point probably when Bolland gets back.
Give him Mason Raymond's spot. Time to end that experiment.
Corn Flake said:Give him Mason Raymond's spot. Time to end that experiment.
Crucialness Key said:Corn Flake said:Highlander said:Kadri may have to switch to winger at some point probably when Bolland gets back.
Give him Mason Raymond's spot. Time to end that experiment.
Didn't Bolland and Raymond have mad chemistry though? Granted that could have been part of MayRay's hot start.