Bender said:
Not a magical deal, but I still think overall it was better to take a chance on Jiggy than stick with Toskala, and an extra year of Jason Blake.
Toskala's deal was up, so he was gone anyway. Like Deebo said, Toskala is largely irrelevant to the deal and there's no chance that they would have re-signed him.
I don't know how the deal plays in a hockey sense. Giguere was pretty bad last year and I didn't see Blake play much but his numbers range from ok to useless.
In hindsight it probably deserves a shrug of the shoulders. Not a bad risk to take but not one that played out particularly well.