• For users coming over from tmlfans.ca your username will remain the same but you will need to use the password reset feature (check your spam folder) on the login page in order to set your password. If you encounter issues, email Rick couchmanrick@gmail.com

General Leafs Talk

Status
Not open for further replies.
So at what stage do we as the fans or management consider a good time to start apologizing to Brian Burke ? Just curious.
 
Mack674 said:
So at what stage do we as the fans or management consider a good time to start apologizing to Brian Burke ? Just curious.

What are they apologizing for?
 
Snoop Lion said:
Mack674 said:
So at what stage do we as the fans or management consider a good time to start apologizing to Brian Burke ? Just curious.

What are they apologizing for?

Yeah us fans didn't do anything.  The people that fired burke likely would not hire him back either.  It wasn't about the team he put together but rather his personality; which was the reason he was canned.
 
Rebel_1812 said:
Snoop Lion said:
Mack674 said:
So at what stage do we as the fans or management consider a good time to start apologizing to Brian Burke ? Just curious.

What are they apologizing for?

Yeah us fans didn't do anything.  The people that fired burke likely would not hire him back either.  It wasn't about the team he put together but rather his personality; which was the reason he was canned.

lol not aimed at anyone in particular but plenty of people around here were calling for his head and rejoiced when he was fired. I liked him, for the record. Hell I like anybody that isn't afraid to tell it like it is and doesn't play politician all the time.

Personality be damned, this is a results driven industry. Here are the Leafs poised for their best finish in 7 seasons and the guy that put the team together doesn't even work here lol. Oh Toronto.
 
Mack674 said:
Rebel_1812 said:
Snoop Lion said:
Mack674 said:
So at what stage do we as the fans or management consider a good time to start apologizing to Brian Burke ? Just curious.

What are they apologizing for?

Yeah us fans didn't do anything.  The people that fired burke likely would not hire him back either.  It wasn't about the team he put together but rather his personality; which was the reason he was canned.

lol not aimed at anyone in particular but plenty of people around here were calling for his head and rejoiced when he was fired. I liked him, for the record. Hell I like anybody that isn't afraid to tell it like it is and doesn't play politician all the time.

Personality be damned, this is a results driven industry. Here are the Leafs poised for their best finish in 7 seasons and the guy that put the team together doesn't even work here lol. Oh Toronto.

Hey now, Burke had no part in bringing in McLaren.
 
Mack674 said:
Personality be damned, this is a results driven industry. Here are the Leafs poised for their best finish in 7 seasons and the guy that put the team together doesn't even work here lol. Oh Toronto.

Maybe it's a by-product of being old enough to remember when it happened with some degree of regularity but I'm not inclined to lose my mind with gratitude at the prospect of the Leafs being poised to be one of the 16 of 30 NHL teams who will make the NHL playoffs. That the Leafs "best result in 7 years" is that as of now they look to be in that top 53% of all NHL teams is less an accomplishment that needs acknowledgement and more a testament to the failures of JFJ, Fletcher and, yes, Brian Burke over those seven years.

You say it's a results driven industry and, quite frankly, the results Burke got were justification enough for his firing, personality concerns aside.
 
When you consider the state this team was in when Burke took over, Im impressed at where it sits now. I don't envy any other GM in the league having to do the same. I at least saw consistent improvement year to year while he was here. It didn't always translate to consistent improvements in the win column but you could tell it was coming around.

I think the loyalty to Wilson is what got him fired. Had he canned Ron much earlier in the year or even before and had Carlyle come in....

anyway what's done is done. I just think it's funny how little mention he gets these days now that the team is sitting in the playoffs finally and could actually push for home ice advantage and while he was still here during worse times there was no shortage of people to point the finger.
 
Nik said:
Mack674 said:
Personality be damned, this is a results driven industry. Here are the Leafs poised for their best finish in 7 seasons and the guy that put the team together doesn't even work here lol. Oh Toronto.

Maybe it's a by-product of being old enough to remember when it happened with some degree of regularity but I'm not inclined to lose my mind with gratitude at the prospect of the Leafs being poised to be one of the 16 of 30 NHL teams who will make the NHL playoffs. That the Leafs "best result in 7 years" is that as of now they look to be in that top 53% of all NHL teams is less an accomplishment that needs acknowledgement and more a testament to the failures of JFJ, Fletcher and, yes, Brian Burke over those seven years.

You say it's a results driven industry and, quite frankly, the results Burke got were justification enough for his firing, personality concerns aside.

They are better than just being in the top 53%. At this point, they appear to be a top 10 team in the NHL and have plenty of cap space to improve going forward. I'd say Burke left the Leafs great shape to become a contender.
 
Deebo said:
They are better than just being in the top 53%. At this point, they appear to be a top 10 team in the NHL and have plenty of cap space to improve going forward. I'd say Burke left the Leafs great shape to become a contender.

I think that's a subject that's been discussed at length elsewhere and clearly opinions run the gamut on the topic. As to the "top 53%" that was more in reference to the idea that the Leafs look poised to have their best finish in 7 years, the dividing line there being the playoffs.
 
Nik said:
As to the "top 53%" that was more in reference to the idea that the Leafs look poised to have their best finish in 7 years, the dividing line there being the playoffs.

Your post said you are "not inclined to lose (your) mind with gratitude at the prospect of the Leafs being poised to be one of the 16 of 30 NHL teams teams who will make the NHL playoffs"

How about top 8 (where they are now)? Is that good enough? What is good enough with the group that Burke assembled for you to say he did a good job?

Or is just that his 3 full seasons here were non-playoff years and that's enough to say he did a bad job?

I'm trying to understand the basis of your evaluation of the job he did.
 
Deebo said:
Your post said you are "not inclined to lose (your) mind with gratitude at the prospect of the Leafs being poised to be one of the 16 of 30 NHL teams teams who will make the NHL playoffs"

How about top 8 (where they are now)? Is that good enough? What is good enough with the group that Burke assembled for you to say he did a good job?

Or is just that his 3 full seasons here were non-playoff years and that's enough to say he did a bad job?

I'm trying to understand the basis of your evaluation of the job he did.

Not to get bogged down in minutiae or anything but the Leafs right now fall just outside of the top 8, being tied for 9th with Vancouver in terms of points winning percentage.

Anyways, I think for starters I'd say that any sort of back slapping is going to be first and foremost be based on something definite. A week or so ago the Leafs were very much just barely in the playoffs and now are a notch above that based on two good weeks. Two bad weeks and they could be there again so right now any sort of congratulations are premature.

As to the larger point, I don't think that what happens this year is going to be a definitive statement either way. The evaluation of the job that Burke did is really going to be how they're poised for the future.

On a side note though, I don't think that we should be so quick to dismiss this as Nonis' team regardless of what players he did or didn't add(and, again, he definitely had a hand in bringing guys to this team even before Burke was fired). Lots of new managers can get drastically improved results without making big changes to personnel. That the Leafs are doing a lot better this year with many of the players who did poorly last year doesn't mean Nonis doesn't deserve a legitimate share of the credit for their success.
 
That is a good point. It is not as if Nonis just became a manager this year. Burke used to give him credit for making some of the deals.
 
caveman said:
That is a good point. It is not as if Nonis just became a manager this year. Burke used to give him credit for making some of the deals.

I agree, Nonis has had a lot to do with building the team, I just think Burke did as well.
 
As someone who strongly disliked Burke because of his bluster and ego, I will eat crow on that and say that the team has improved and he certainly did have a positive impact.

That being said, I'm very happy he did what he did, and now the reigns are in Nonis' hands.
 
Here is a preview on the remaining games/teams Leafs will play:

http://bleacherreport.com/articles/1589454-toronto-maple-leafs-previewing-the-rest-of-the-season
 
Could a Keith Yandle help the Leafs?  Think it's worth for Nonis to get him?

According to Bruce Garrioch of the Ottawa Sun, Yandle is available: The only impact blueliner available is Keith Yandleof the Phoenix Coyotes, who wouldn't mind shedding his $5.25 million salary.

...Yandle is a defenseman who can play in all three zones and will give you well over 20 minutes of ice time per game.While Yandle would certainly be the most expensive of these three options, he'd be more than worth the cost and could really help the Leafs in their own end, as well as on the powerplay and in the offensive zone. 


Souroe:  bIeacherreport
 
cabber24 said:
Darren Dreger ‏@DarrenDreger 43s

Ryan O'Byrne to Toronto for a 4th rounder. #tradecentre

thats exactly the type of trade i was hoping we'd make. solid stay at home type to clear the front of the net. now kostka sits hopefully. Final pairing should be Liles and O'Byrne
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

About Us

This website is NOT associated with the Toronto Maple Leafs or the NHL.


It is operated by Rick Couchman and Jeff Lewis.
Back
Top