• For users coming over from tmlfans.ca your username will remain the same but you will need to use the password reset feature (check your spam folder) on the login page in order to set your password. If you encounter issues, email Rick couchmanrick@gmail.com

Ranking Prospects 2019-2020

herman said:
Frank E said:
What happened to Der Arguchintsev this past season?

Played on a bad team and had a poor showing on the stats sheet. Playmaking centre with wingers without finish = 0___0

But 1G 1A in 3 Growlers games

Playmaking centre might be a bit of an overstatement, given his 46 points in 62 games in the O.

6 goals :(
 
Frank E said:
herman said:
Frank E said:
What happened to Der Arguchintsev this past season?

Played on a bad team and had a poor showing on the stats sheet. Playmaking centre with wingers without finish = 0___0

But 1G 1A in 3 Growlers games

Playmaking centre might be a bit of an overstatement, given his 46 points in 62 games in the O.

6 goals :(

That's his literal style of play: he's a passer, not a shooter.

He is also the youngest player in his draft cohort, so there's a year of development there to account for in comparison. That said, his D+1 looked worse than his D-0.
 
herman said:
Frank E said:
herman said:
Frank E said:
What happened to Der Arguchintsev this past season?

Played on a bad team and had a poor showing on the stats sheet. Playmaking centre with wingers without finish = 0___0

But 1G 1A in 3 Growlers games

Playmaking centre might be a bit of an overstatement, given his 46 points in 62 games in the O.

6 goals :(

That's his literal style of play: he's a passer, not a shooter.

So not so much a playmaker as a playtryer.
 
herman said:
Trying not to overthink this

1. Auston Matthews
2. Mitch Marner
3. William Nylander
4. Kasperi Kapanen
5. Travis Dermott
6. Alexander Kerfoot
7. Andreas Johnsson
8. Rasmus Sandin
9. Timothy Liljegren
10. Nic Petan
11. Trevor Moore
12. Ilya Mikheyev
13. Nick Robertson
14. Egor Korshkov
15. Jeremy Bracco
16. Teemu Kivihalme
17. Pierre Engvall
18. Joseph Woll
19. Ian Scott
20. Mac Hollowell
21. Joseph Duszak
22. Semyon Der Arguchintsev
23. Adam Brooks
24. Kasimir Kaskisuo
25. Mikko Kokkonen

I haven't really seen enough of the back half to be even remotely sure.

Totally forgot Borgman. Oh wells.
 
herman said:
herman said:
Trying not to overthink this

1. Auston Matthews
2. Mitch Marner
3. William Nylander
4. Kasperi Kapanen
5. Travis Dermott
6. Alexander Kerfoot
7. Andreas Johnsson
8. Rasmus Sandin
9. Timothy Liljegren
10. Nic Petan
11. Trevor Moore
12. Ilya Mikheyev
13. Nick Robertson
14. Egor Korshkov
15. Jeremy Bracco
16. Teemu Kivihalme
17. Pierre Engvall
18. Joseph Woll
19. Ian Scott
20. Mac Hollowell
21. Joseph Duszak
22. Semyon Der Arguchintsev
23. Adam Brooks
24. Kasimir Kaskisuo
25. Mikko Kokkonen

I haven't really seen enough of the back half to be even remotely sure.

Totally forgot Borgman. Oh wells.
And Marchment who might challenge for a 4th line spot this season.
 
A Weekend at Bernier's said:
Nik the Trik said:
Man, that is one hell of a wasteland after #9.

Maybe, but I think Trevor Moore has shown enough to be considered above the wasteland bar.
Trevor Moore, Trevor Moore and his horse Concord, He steals from the poor to give to the rich, silly b__tch!!
 
Frank E said:
herman said:
Frank E said:
What happened to Der Arguchintsev this past season?

Played on a bad team and had a poor showing on the stats sheet. Playmaking centre with wingers without finish = 0___0

But 1G 1A in 3 Growlers games

Playmaking centre might be a bit of an overstatement, given his 46 points in 62 games in the O.

6 goals :(


Keep in mind he's still only 18. Was really really young so let's give him a chance to grow.
 
25. Joseph Duszak

I had him at 21 on my off-the-cuff list, largely because he was ELC'd out of college by this front office and plays a position of elevated value in the league with the tools I like to see (strong, improvable skating; puck confidence). He'll get a full AHL season to calibrate his game speed and we'll have a better idea next year.
 
herman said:
Totally forgot Borgman. Oh wells.

1jqcf8.jpg
 
24. Frederik Gauthier

He has turned out better than I ever could have expected yet still sort of hovers at the slightly below replacement level mark. Why he hasn't been traded to Montreal, who is in semi-desperate need of centres, yet is beyond me.
 
herman said:
24. Frederik Gauthier

He has turned out better than I ever could have expected yet still sort of hovers at the slightly below replacement level mark. Why he hasn't been traded to Montreal, who is in semi-desperate need of centres, yet is beyond me.
13 forward at best this season. He shouldn't be on the team.
 
Guilt Trip said:
herman said:
24. Frederik Gauthier

He has turned out better than I ever could have expected yet still sort of hovers at the slightly below replacement level mark. Why he hasn't been traded to Montreal, who is in semi-desperate need of centres, yet is beyond me.
13 forward at best this season. He shouldn't be on the team.

At best he's probably #16.
 
Coco-puffs said:
Guilt Trip said:
herman said:
24. Frederik Gauthier

He has turned out better than I ever could have expected yet still sort of hovers at the slightly below replacement level mark. Why he hasn't been traded to Montreal, who is in semi-desperate need of centres, yet is beyond me.
13 forward at best this season. He shouldn't be on the team.

At best he's probably #16.

He?s like 3C on the Marlies at most lol
 
herman said:
Coco-puffs said:
Guilt Trip said:
herman said:
24. Frederik Gauthier

He has turned out better than I ever could have expected yet still sort of hovers at the slightly below replacement level mark. Why he hasn't been traded to Montreal, who is in semi-desperate need of centres, yet is beyond me.
13 forward at best this season. He shouldn't be on the team.

At best he's probably #16.

He?s like 3C on the Marlies at most lol
Lets stop all this Goat bashing!!!!
 
Coco-puffs said:
Guilt Trip said:
herman said:
24. Frederik Gauthier

He has turned out better than I ever could have expected yet still sort of hovers at the slightly below replacement level mark. Why he hasn't been traded to Montreal, who is in semi-desperate need of centres, yet is beyond me.
13 forward at best this season. He shouldn't be on the team.

At best he's probably #16.
I wouldn't even rank him that high. I guess I should have said best case for us, the fans, is that he never makes it above the 13th forward position.
 
Back
Top